Find all hotels by Best Western in Fire Island, NY from $142

Check Fire Island hotel availability

Compare rooms and suites by Best Western in Fire Island with rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.

"Front desk agent was so nice and helpful she’s super kind and sweet thank you "

$158 total

includes taxes & fees

Jun 16 - Jun 17

"Good location out of Manhattan area. 35min train ride to Penn Station. Lots of restaurants in walking distance."

$223 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 1 - Jul 2

Best Western Fire Island Hotel Guide

Some globe-trotters choose hotels based on location, but others book by name. And thanks to Expedia you don’t have to pick. It is why we offer such an expansive range of Best Western hotels in Fire Island, New York. Known for well-appointed rooms and friendly, personalized service, each of the top Best Western Fire Island hotels guarantees an unparalleled level of comfort and quality.

You’ll find best-in-class amenities like clean rooms and quiet atmospheres, and some Fire Island Best Western locations may even offer extra little benefits and discounts for frequent travelers.